Today’s unexpected Supreme Court victory could exempt more gig workers from forced arbitration

Today, the Supreme Court settled a long-standing split among lower courts about which kinds of transportation workers qualify for a federal limit on forced arbitration—and, surprisingly, the justices voted unanimously to expand that class of workers. The case at hand involved an airplane cargo supervisor, Latrice Saxon, who took Southwest Airlines to court for overtime issues back in 2019. Southwest argued she couldn’t do that because she was bound by an arbitration agreement. Saxon’s lawyers argued she fell under a carveout in the Federal Arbitration Act for “seamen, railroad employees, or any other class of workers engaged in foreign or interstate commerce.” That’s the argument that worked its way up to the country’s top court, which ruled that cargo workers like her do indeed qualify, expanding the size of that carveout at a time when employers have made increasing use of forced arbitration to quash employees’ power to file class-action lawsuits. A split over where to draw the line for that federal carveout has been open for years, resulting in contradictory court opinions for a whole host of industries—a big reason why the Supreme Court took the case. An earlier Supreme Court decision in 2001, one frequently criticized for being anti-worker, ruled that the federal carveout must be narrowly interpreted to apply to only “transportation workers,” without explaining what, exactly, a “transpiration worker” was. Complicating matters, a lower court in 2019 took the initiative to define “any other class of workers” to include not just employees, but contract workers, too. That caused employers in a number of transportation or transportation-adjacent industries—notably Amazon and Uber—to file amicus briefs arguing that this latest case, Southwest Airlines v. Saxon, would affect how courts ruled on similar lawsuits filed against them. (Some of those cases were even paused while the Supreme Court heard Saxon.) Ultimately it comes down to that federal carveout being passed in 1925, back when today’s transportation sector was unthinkable, and decades before the advent of the gig worker. Saxon was being closely watched for its effect on these newcomer gig-worker roles, particularly independent contractors who drive for Uber or deliver for Amazon. However, this opinion by the justices is said not to have ventured much beyond the scope of Saxon and Southwest’s situation, meaning they merely confirmed the federal carveout applies to airplane cargo loaders and unloaders. For the bigger question of how this impacts the broader gig economy and employers like Amazon and Uber, those issues have been punted to a later day.

https://www.fastcompany.com/90758727/todays-unexpected-supreme-court-victory-could-exempt-more-gig-workers-from-forced-arbitration?partner=rss&utm_source=rss&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=rss+fastcompany&utm_content=rss

Created 3y | Jun 7, 2022, 8:20:51 PM


Login to add comment

Other posts in this group

This fintech startup’s $100 million fund aims to get influencers paid faster

Influencers, how many late payments are you waiting on? Odds are, more than one.

Influencer marketing is a booming $

Mar 25, 2025, 6:10:08 AM | Fast company - tech
How to cautiously use health advice from social media

In the corners of social media dominated by

Mar 24, 2025, 6:30:09 PM | Fast company - tech
TikTok has a big ADHD problem

ADHD content has been trending on TikTok for a while. Unsurprisingly, much of it has been found to be misleading. 

A study published last week

Mar 24, 2025, 4:20:05 PM | Fast company - tech
Section 230 faces bipartisan repeal effort. Experts say it’s a risky bet

Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act—the provision that protects tech platforms from legal liability for content posted by their users—has long been a point of contention among lawmakers.

Mar 24, 2025, 4:20:04 PM | Fast company - tech
Flexport CEO Ryan Petersen on what business leaders need to know about Trump’s tariffs

Trump’s tariff war is causing vast disruption across international trade. Ryan Petersen, foun

Mar 24, 2025, 1:50:06 PM | Fast company - tech
How ‘The Matrix’ helped build—and break—beleaguered production company Village Roadhouse

The name Village Roadshow might not ring a bell with every moviegoer, but "> the company’s logo almost certainly will. Its shimmering, nested

Mar 24, 2025, 11:40:02 AM | Fast company - tech
Would you pay $4,000 to solve your streaming movie problems?

Let’s say you were spending tens of thousands of dollars to build yourself a fancy home theater. How would you go about actually watching movies in it?

While you could always set u

Mar 24, 2025, 9:20:04 AM | Fast company - tech