Microsoft’s Majorana 1 widened the quantum field. But are we any closer to a eureka moment?

Quantum researchers are in a race for qubits, and Microsoft is in the thick of the competition.

Microsoft has spent the last 20 years pursuing a topological approach to quantum development. Last week, they had a breakthrough: The company counted eight topological qubits on their Majorana 1 chip. They published a paper in Nature, got a glowing New York Times piece about a “new state of matter,” and buoyed quantum stocks across the market. 

Eight qubits isn’t anywhere near what would be needed to reach full-scale quantum computing. That number is in the millions, and they would need to be error-corrected. Other companies, like IBM and Google, are much further ahead on that—just with different models. Microsoft finally proved that the topological approach could work; now, they’ve got to catch up. (Think of it like discovering a new way to build a car engine: Microsoft just got theirs to start, while others are already racing down the track.) There are reasons to be excited—namely, that a topological approach could be less susceptible to noise—but they’re still vastly behind in scale. 

“If anybody believes this means that Microsoft is close to a commercial quantum computer, they’re missing the point,” says Alan Baratz, CEO of D-Wave Quantum, a rival quantum company. “It’s a validation that [topological] is a viable approach. Will it be a better approach than superconducting or trapped ion or photonic or neutral atom? That remains to be seen.”

The many paths to quantum computing

All of our computers operate using “bits,” the smallest unit of digital information. This bit can be either a zero or a one. Quantum researchers are now developing bits that can be both zero and one at the same time—something that would dramatically speed up computations. These “qubits” are difficult to develop, even harder to scale, and almost impossible to correct for errors. Still, researchers at major companies have made significant progress. 

But there’s not one singular way to build a qubit. The most prominent approach to making a qubit relies on superconducting circuits—Google, IBM, and Amazon Web Services have all bet big on that. Another is the photonic technique, which uses light particles as qubits; that’s being developed domestically by PsiQuantum and Xanadu, and overseas by Chinese researcher Jian-Wei Pan. Each has shown promise, but most still face major hurdles, keeping large-scale, error-corrected quantum computing years away.

Microsoft has added a topological approach to the rat race. “[For other modalities], we’ve demonstrated the physics as a community. Now it’s about scale,” says Jack Hidary, CEO of AI company SandboxAQ. “In the case of topological, it’s the one modality that needed a fundamental science breakthrough.” 

But, while Microsoft has reached their “science breakthrough,” other companies have pushed further. Both Hidary and Baratz reference Google’s Willow chip, which employs the superconducting approach. Not only did Willow employ significantly more qubits, but it also proved that error-correction was scalable. The more qubits, Google found, the more they reduced error. 

“They were able to show partial error correction on gate model qubits for the first time, and that’s critically important,” Baratz says. “That’s a true advance. I think [Majorana 1] is just a proof of concept widening.”

Baratz is, like a number of physicists, generally skeptical of the Microsoft announcement. He references Microsoft’s previous failure in the arena: After publishing a 2018 paper in Nature claiming a Majorana discovery, quantum researchers began to question their findings. Microsoft’s scientists admitted “insufficient scientific rigour” in 2021, and Nature retracted the paper. Baratz also notes that the paper ignored qubit or gate fidelity, both measures of accuracy. “It leads you to wonder, what is this chip actually capable of doing, and to what extent is it actually a process?” he asks. 

For their part, Microsoft is embracing the spirit of competition. “Others are working to bring this same vision to life, but with different approaches,” a Microsoft spokesperson wrote in an email to Fast Company. “This is what makes science fun. Some in the field believe an alternative approach is the right one to take and have invested significant time and resources into their methods. We understand why they would want to advocate for their approach. Discourse and skepticism are all part of the scientific process.”

Still, there’s a reason scientists continue to call Microsoft’s paper a “breakthrough.” While the company may not have anything close to a quantum computer—or even a lead in the race to get there—they’ve pulled off something thought previously unimaginable. Most had simply given up on the topological approach.

“The topological approach is the most scientifically daunting approach to building a quantum computer, and that’s why Microsoft deserves credit,” Hidary says. “Kudos.” 

How far are we from full-scale, marketable quantum computing? That’s still unknown. But experts like Karthee Madasmy, who was an early investor in PsiQuantum, thinks the Microsoft news is yet another good sign. The timeline has shrunk, he says. 

“It’s not multiple decades away,” Madasmy says. “It’s actually a few years away.” 

https://www.fastcompany.com/91285143/microsofts-quantum-breakthrough-a-major-step-or-a-science-experiment?partner=rss&utm_source=rss&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=rss+fastcompany&utm_content=rss

Utworzony 1mo | 26 lut 2025, 11:40:02


Zaloguj się, aby dodać komentarz

Inne posty w tej grupie

Tinder wants you to flirt with an AI bot before you flop with a human

Think you’ve got game? Time to put it to the test with Tinder’s latest launch in collaboration with OpenAI.

On Tuesday, Tinder rolled out The Game Game—a new experience designed to help

1 kwi 2025, 21:20:06 | Fast company - tech
‘Imagine having Cybertruck money and buying a Cybertruck’: TikTok is full of people trading in their Teslas to the sounds of Taylor Swift

The old Tesla can’t come to the phone right now. Why? Oh, ‘cause she’s dead.

Over the past few days, a new trend has emerged on TikTok: people are posting their Tesla trade-ins accompani

1 kwi 2025, 19:10:03 | Fast company - tech
Kickstarter isn’t just for indie passion projects anymore

Despite a ">triumphant world premiere at Cannes last May, the politically unsparing Donald Trump biopic The Apprentice was stuck in

1 kwi 2025, 16:40:05 | Fast company - tech
‘inZOI’ challenges ‘The Sims’ with a fresh take on life simulation

Countless hours, days—perhaps even weeks—of my life have been spent creating Sims characters, building them houses, marrying them off, and making babies. Now, there’s a new life-simulatio

1 kwi 2025, 14:20:11 | Fast company - tech
SpaceX flight launches 4 space tourists into first-ever polar orbit

A bitcoin investor who bought a SpaceX flight for himself and three polar explorers blasted

1 kwi 2025, 14:20:10 | Fast company - tech
AI researchers want to map the 3D world. That means going vertical—and possibly nuclear

Spatial intelligence is an emerging approach to deploying AI in the physical world. By combining mapping data with artificial intelligence, it aims to deliver “smart data” tied to specific locatio

1 kwi 2025, 12:10:05 | Fast company - tech
3 years into war with Russia, this Ukrainian startup is powering a drone revolution

Ukraine’s war with Russia—sparked by Russia’s invasion in the spring of 2022—is now entering its fourth year. So t

1 kwi 2025, 12:10:04 | Fast company - tech