The Kamala Harris Google ad controversy explained

Kamala Harris’s campaign has been editing headlines and story descriptions from news outlets within Google search ads to appear favorable to the vice president, Axios reported this week. Now former President Donald Trump is calling out Google and the Harris campaign for the practice. 

Here’s your quick explainer on the Harris ad controversy:

What is the Harris campaign doing with Google ads?

Harris’s campaign edited the news headlines and accompanying descriptions that appear as part of Google search ads so that it seems certain outlets are on her side. Axios found nearly a dozen news companies being used in these types of search ads since August 3. 

Yes, this is a legal practice and it doesn’t violate Google’s policies. In fact, the tactic has been used by previous campaigns. But some experts say it presents ethical concerns, according to USA Today. The ads include a “Sponsored” tag, but voters may not realize that the text that accompanies the ads is written by the campaign and not by the news outlets. 

For example, an ad running alongside an article from the Associated Press showed an altered headline that said “VP Harris’s Economic Vision – Lower Costs And Higher Wages.” The description underneath, which is meant to share a few sentences about the story, said, “A future where every person has the opportunity not just to get by but to get ahead.” (The Harris campaign didn’t respond to Fast Company’s request for comment.)

What does Google say? 

“These ads are explicitly labeled as ‘Sponsored’ so that they’re easily distinguishable from Search results and they also include ‘Paid for by’ disclosures so it’s clear to users who paid for them,” a Google spokesperson said in a statement. “It’s fairly common for advertisers to link out to or cite external websites, including news sites, in their ads.”

But platforms have grappled with how to deal with these types of ads. Facebook banned advertisers from editing text from similar ads linking to news outlets in 2017, citing efforts to stop the spread of fake news and misinformation. 

So how is Trump involved?

The Trump campaign isn’t running these types of ads, Axios reported. But the former president is using the Axios report to criticize the Harris campaign and Google. “Wow! Google and the Harris Campaign are manipulating stories. Is this legal?” Trump posted on social media. The thing is, members of the Harris campaign aren’t changing the stories. They’re altering the way the stories appear on Google search, and at the end of the day this is a common practice.

Trump isn’t running these ads right now, but other high-profile Republicans have in the past, according to Google’s Political Ads Transparency Center. Those include Brian Kemp for Governor, Rodney Davis for Congress, the short-lived Marsha Blackburn for Senate campaign, and Mike Braun for Indiana.

How are news outlets responding?

Publishers appear to have been unaware that their brands were showing up in ads. “While we understand why an organization might wish to align itself with The Guardian’s trusted brand, we need to ensure it is being used appropriately and with our permission. We’ll be reaching out to Google for more information about this practice,” a Guardian spokesperson told Axios

An Associated Press spokesperson told USA Today that the news outlet “was neither aware of this practice nor would we allow these to run on our website.”

<hr class=“wp-block-separator is-style-wide”/> https://www.fastcompany.com/91173357/kamala-harris-ad-controversy-explained?partner=rss&amp;utm_source=rss&amp;utm_medium=feed&amp;utm_campaign=rss+fastcompany&amp;utm_content=rss

Creată 6mo | 15 aug. 2024, 09:30:02


Autentifică-te pentru a adăuga comentarii

Alte posturi din acest grup

How Factory is turning AI into ‘a junior developer in a box’

Many things remain uncertain about AI’s future impact on our lives. One that isn’t in doubt is that more and more of the world’s software will be written, at least in part, by software. A

25 feb. 2025, 19:20:08 | Fast company - tech
Why Donald Trump and Elon Musk probably aren’t breaking up any time soon

On Monday morning, anonymous hackers played a video on screens throughout the Department of Housing and Urban Development HQ in Washington, D.C. The AI-generated video jankily portrayed President

25 feb. 2025, 19:20:08 | Fast company - tech
Chengdu’s Snow Village faces backlash for creating a fake winter wonder

There’s a new entrant in the scam hall of fame.

The Chengdu Snow Village—a newly opened destination in the suburban Chengdu, Sichuan province—advertised a picturesque snow landscap

25 feb. 2025, 19:20:07 | Fast company - tech
How LinkedIn became luxury fashion’s newest runway

As Fashion Week takes over New York, London, and Milan, designers aren’t just showcasing their collections on the runway—they’re taking over

25 feb. 2025, 17:10:06 | Fast company - tech
Kate Bush, Annie Lennox, and a slew of other stars are on this silent album. Here’s why

A new album called “Is This What We Want?” features a stellar list of more than 1,000 musicians—and the sound of silence.

With contributions from artists including Kate Bush, An

25 feb. 2025, 17:10:06 | Fast company - tech
Inside Trello’s reinvention as a personal tasks app

Riddle me this: What exactly is Trello?

Despite counting myself as a heavy-duty power user of the product for well over a decade now, it’s a question I’ve long struggled to answer. Techn

25 feb. 2025, 14:40:08 | Fast company - tech
This music publisher wants to help ‘middle-class’ songwriters get the money they’re owed

The trope of the starving, broke artist has long maintained a place in the public imagination, even as it has morphed into idealized notions of “‘hustle” or “grindset.” “It’s cool to romanticize [

25 feb. 2025, 12:30:05 | Fast company - tech