Asus’ Q-Release Slim motherboards can scratch GPU connectors

">The first version merely reroutes the release tab from the end of the slot (and often under the bulk of the card) to a much more accessible spot.

But the Q-Release Slim found on high-end 2024 motherboards is more complex, physically gripping the card’s connection area and releasing it without any buttons, only with specific pressure from the side of the card facing the rear of the case. If you try to pull the card out from the middle or the rear, it won’t work. Here’s an example of it working… uh, sort of:

At least, that’s the idea. Schilling alleges that the system is a lot more finicky in practice, making it harder to get a card out than intended. And of course the damage in the photo will cause any PC builder to wince, whether or not they see it on a $2,000 card. The damage appears to be cosmetic… but pressure on that same spot could be a lot worse, as there’s less than an inch of PCB on that tab.

It’s worth noting that hardware reviewers are harder on these delicate components than end users, as a matter of course. While I might install a card three or four times over its lifetime with system upgrades and maintenance, a reviewer like Adam or Brad could perform the same number of actions on a single card or motherboard in just one day.

Schilling said that this particular slot had cards in and out of it “a few dozen times” on the test motherboard. Uniko’s Hardware (via Tom’s Hardware) showed a Bilibili user photo with a Q-Release Slim retention peg on the PCIe slot with visible damage after 60 actuations.

These examples of visible damage are relatively limited, but PCWorld’s Adam Patrick Murray agrees that Q-Release Slim has some issues. “Ever since I first started building PCs, I’ve learned to never yank on anything in that slot,” he told me in our company chat. “Now Asus is asking me to go against everything in my body to yank on it? No thanks. I’ve been yanking on it since CES and it NEVER feels okay.”

I don’t think this is something a regular user needs to be imminently scared of. Even the few examples that have visible damage aren’t actually affecting the pins. And, again, what we’re seeing is for usage that’s far beyond any standard PC builder. That said, if something DID happen to an expensive graphics card or motherboard, I can imagine it would be a huge headache if two different manufacturers started pointing fingers at each other during the RMA process.

https://www.pcworld.com/article/2588049/asus-q-release-slim-motherboards-can-scratch-gpu-connectors.html